19/11/2026
Written by Rick Liddiment
Stakeholder engagement has become increasingly systematic. We map power and interest, identify decision-makers, agree messages, assign relationship owners and record the next action. These tools are valuable because they bring focus and discipline to work that can otherwise become reactive or inconsistent.
But they cannot tell us what someone genuinely cares about. They cannot sense tension in a room, recognise when an explanation is incomplete or reveal why an apparently minor issue has become deeply important to a person or community. Frameworks can help us decide where to invest our time, but they cannot build the relationship for us.
Reading the work of neuroscientist and researcher Angus Fletcher gave me a different way of thinking about this. Fletcher argues that human intelligence is not purely logical or computational. We experience and interpret the world through stories involving people, emotions, relationships, choices and consequences, rather than simply as disconnected facts.
Fletcher was not writing about stakeholder engagement, but his work provides a useful lens through which to examine it. Relationships depend on capabilities that are often difficult to capture in a contact plan or stakeholder database: emotion, intuition, imagination and common sense.
Emotion helps us understand what matters. A conversation may appear to be about parking, antisocial behaviour, development or service performance, while underneath it may be about safety, identity, dignity or whether somebody feels heard. Intuition helps us notice what does not quite fit: the apparently positive response that conceals a concern, the formal leader who is not truly shaping the room or the explanation that does not fully account for the strength of someone’s reaction.
Imagination allows us to see more than one possible ending. Effective engagement should not simply be an attempt to persuade someone to accept an answer we have already developed. It should also help us identify areas of shared interest and consider possibilities that were not visible at the beginning. Commonsense then helps us decide what the particular moment requires, even when the available information is incomplete and the formal process does not account for every local reality. In the session I developed from these ideas, the four capabilities became a simple sequence: we care about something, notice something, imagine possibilities and decide what to do.
This resonated with me because much of my own work has involved complex or ambiguous situations where the formal structure only explains part of what is happening. The value is often found in reading the wider context, joining apparently separate issues and understanding the relationships beneath the organisation chart. Fletcher’s work did not create that instinct, but it gave me a clearer language for it.
Curiosity before judgement
Curiosity is where these ideas become especially practical. We often build rapport by sharing common ground. We say, “That happened to me too,” or, “I know exactly what you mean.” There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but it can unintentionally shift the conversation from the other person’s experience to our own.
Something similar can happen when we ask “why” too quickly. Imagine that someone says they have turned down a home they were offered. Asking why may produce the answer that it was too small. We now have an explanation and may believe we understand the decision.
However, asking what was important about their previous home, who lives with them, what made the decision difficult and how they reached it may reveal a much richer story. The issue may be proximity to family, the loss of an informal support network, a child’s need for familiarity or a fear of no longer feeling safe.
The point is not that “why” is a bad question. It is that asking it too early can produce a neat explanation before we have properly explored the experience. Curiosity helps us discover the story before deciding what it means.
This also helps explain how intuition develops. Every genuinely curious conversation adds detail to our understanding of people, organisations and places. Over time, that accumulated experience makes it easier to recognise patterns and notice when something does not fit. Intuition is not certainty or a substitute for evidence. It is a signal that something deserves closer attention.
Strategy still matters
None of this means abandoning stakeholder frameworks. Time, energy and organisational capacity remain limited, so not every relationship can receive the same level of attention. Power-and-interest mapping can help us decide where to collaborate closely, where to build relevance and where proportionate engagement is enough.
The risk comes when the framework becomes a substitute for judgement. The same person may occupy a different position depending on the issue, place or moment. Formal authority also does not always reveal informal influence. The person others listen to may be a longstanding resident, a trusted volunteer, a local business owner or the administrator of a community Facebook group. A stakeholder matrix can tell us where to look. Human intelligence helps us understand what we find.
Trust is the real infrastructure of influence
Influence is sometimes understood as the ability to construct the strongest argument or deliver the most persuasive message. In practice, it is usually built on trust.
Trust rarely comes from one important meeting or one perfect conversation. It develops through repeated behaviour: staying in touch before something is needed, understanding what matters to the other person, sharing useful insight, being clear about ownership, doing what we say we will do and reviewing relationships as people and priorities change.
The best meetings are therefore not always those in which we deliver the perfect message. They are often the ones we leave understanding the other person’s priorities better than when we arrived. Once we understand what matters to somebody, we stop simply trying to convince them and begin looking for where our aims overlap. That is where stakeholder engagement can become a genuine relationship, and where a relationship can develop into partnership.
Data, technology and structured frameworks will continue to improve how we identify stakeholders, process information and prepare for engagement. But no matrix can read a room, no database can fully explain why somebody cares and no approved message can replace genuine understanding.
The future of stakeholder engagement should not be a choice between systematic planning and human intelligence. We need both. Frameworks bring discipline and focus; curiosity, intuition, imagination and common sense help us understand the people and stories within them.
That is ultimately what turns stakeholder management into something more useful: understanding people, building trust and helping organisations act together around what matters.