11/11/2026

Accountability without authority is how place-based working fails

Written by Jane Spikings

Picking up on my previous post, where I set out four key shifts we need to make if place-based working is going to progress long-term and not just survive the length of a pilot. But here’s what those shifts actually demand once you try to put them into practice.

 

Create networks of practice, not just networks of hierarchy

Communities of practice organised around passions, shared challenges, professional expertise and areas of interest can help people connect in ways that traditional structures do not always enable. Imagine people working across the organisation to explore a shared question about place, prevention, community power or customer experience. Their connection is not dependent on being in the same team or reporting to the same manager.

These networks can become places where people learn, experiment, share knowledge and develop new ways of working.

 

Build communication structures that enable dialogue, not just the flow of information

Information is often designed to flow up and down an organisation but transformation requires information to flow across it. People need access to the knowledge, experience and perspectives that will help them make better decisions. They need opportunities to question, challenge, learn and make sense of what is happening together.

This means creating communication structures that enable dialogue, not simply the distribution of messages.

 

Borrow ideas from outside our usual boundaries

There is a risk that, when designing a new operating model, we look only at what other housing associations are doing. Of course, there is much to learn from our sector. But if we want to think differently, we may also need to look beyond it. What can we learn from organisations that have already made the shift from hierarchical control to distributed leadership? From businesses that organise around customer needs rather than functions? From communities that have developed their own solutions to complex local challenges?

We do not need to copy what others have done. We need to understand the thinking behind it and consider what might be useful in our own context.

 

Redesign accountability alongside authority

One of the challenges of place-based working is that people may be given responsibility without having the authority, information or resources to act. If we want decisions to be made closer to communities, we need to be clear about where decisions sit, what people are accountable for and how different forms of expertise contribute. This is particularly important in a housing association, where professional, regulatory and statutory responsibilities cannot simply be removed in the pursuit of greater flexibility.

The opportunity is to move away from unnecessary central control while retaining the oversight, expertise and safeguards that protect customers, colleagues and the organisation.

 

Create space for learning, not just delivery

Transformation will not happen if people are expected to deliver their existing work in the same way while simultaneously designing and testing a new operating system. We need to create time and space for people to learn, reflect and experiment. This might mean protected time for communities of practice, opportunities to share learning across pilots, or regular conversations about what is helping and hindering the change.

If we want people to become more comfortable with uncertainty, we need to create an environment where learning from what does not work is valued alongside celebrating success.

 

Align the systems that shape behaviour

People respond to what the organisation rewards, measures, funds and pays attention to. If our performance measures, governance arrangements, budgets and recognition systems continue to reinforce traditional functional working, it will be difficult for place-based approaches to become embedded. We need to ask whether our organisational systems are aligned with the behaviours we are trying to encourage. Are we measuring the outcomes that matter to places and communities? Are we recognising collaboration across boundaries? Are we allocating resources in ways that enable local solutions?

These are not separate questions from operating model design. They are part of it.

 

What does this mean for current leaders?

None of this means that current leaders need to have all the answers, or that the existing organisation has to be dismantled before anything new can happen. In fact, the opposite may be true. The people who currently lead the organisation have a crucial role in creating the conditions for change. They hold influence, knowledge, relationships and the ability to remove barriers that others cannot. The challenge is to use that influence differently. To be willing to let go of some control while remaining accountable for the direction and purpose of the organisation. To create space for people to lead beyond their formal roles. To listen to what the organisation is telling us through its pilots, its successes and its resistance. And to recognise that sometimes the most important leadership intervention is not to introduce another initiative, but to change something in the environment around it.

This is not about making hierarchy the enemy. Hierarchical structures have developed for good reasons, particularly in a regulated housing environment where accountability, professional expertise and safety matter. The opportunity is to become more intentional about where hierarchy helps, where it gets in the way, and what other forms of coordination and leadership are needed alongside it.

The question is not whether we should have hierarchy or no hierarchy. It is whether our structures and systems help us achieve what we are here to do.

 

A question to leave you with

If we believe that place-based working is not simply a new way of delivering services, but a different way of organising ourselves around the needs and strengths of communities, then we need to think about the organisation differently.

What would we need to change in our structures, systems, leadership and thinking to make this way of working feel less like an exception and more like the natural way we operate?

We cannot change a huge organisation instantly but we can build intentional architecture that supports transformative change. Perhaps the most important question is not whether we can design the perfect operating model, but whether we can create the conditions for something better to emerge.

 

About Jane

Jane Spikings works in Learning & Development at BFL. Read part one of this piece here, or connect with her on LinkedIn.